Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:

Making Heritage in Hong Kong: A Case Study of the Central Police Station Compound

Authors Ku, Agnes Shuk-Mei View this author's profile
Issue Date 2010
Source China quarterly , v. 202, June 2010, p. 381-399
Summary This article is a case study of state society capital conflicts over the preservation of the Central Police Station (CPS) compound in Hong Kong during 2003-08. The conflict was between two fundamentally different approaches to urban space: a cultural economy approach that took culture and space as a source of economic profit, and an opposition discourse of preservation that emphasized cultural, historical and humanistic values as an end. The struggle turned out to be a moderate success for anti-commercialism. Drawing on and extending the notions of collective memory and spatial politics, this article examines how the various civil society actors, in their struggle against commercialism, sought to define and enhance the cultural value of the site through a variety of discourses and practices relating to history and space. It addresses the specific question of why and how certain constructions of collective memory succeed (or fail) to work with certain places in particular instances. The study shows that memories of the CPS compound contained both state-associated and people-associated accounts, between which the former prevailed. The state-associated account was embedded in a familiar, hegemonic story about Hong Kong, which, via an abstract process of symbolization around the notion of the rule of law, successfully turned the compound into an iconic symbol of identification for the city. Beyond this, the civil society actors sought also to generate a sense of lived space associated with the people, and the outcome was mixed.
ISSN 0305-7410
Rights © Cambridge University Press 2010. This paper was published in The China quarterly, v. 202, 2010, p. 381-399 and is reprinted with permission.
Language English
Format Article
Access View full-text via DOI
View full-text via Web of Science
View full-text via Scopus
Files in this item:
File Description Size Format
MakingHeritage.pdf 125637 B Adobe PDF